
A (Plea) Offer You Can Refuse
David S. Abrams, Viet Nguyen, Aurelie Ouss, Julia Reinhold · Journal of Legal Studies (2026) · Forthcoming
Using data on initial plea offers in Philadelphia felony cases, this paper shows that rejected offers are often longer than eventual sentences, even after trial convictions. The findings challenge standard empirical approaches to measuring the trial penalty and show that relying on accepted pleas as counterfactuals can misstate both the magnitude and direction of the trial penalty.

























